Pairing Software and ECF Grading Submission File
-
- Posts: 1235
- Joined: Tue Jul 02, 2013 7:36 am
- Location: Hertfordshire
Pairing Software and ECF Grading Submission File
I have just bought a licence for UTU Swiss, the rebadged version of Tournament Director, on the basis that it promises to do pairings for tournaments and generate ECF grading submission files.
It appears that it will only output a text file if its contents complies fully with the ECF grading submission rules. I am not a registered grader and do not have the means to register new players which UTU Swiss identifies as data errors.
Has anyone else any experience of UTU Swiss and got to output anything useful that can be sent to an ECF grader when the tournament includes unregistered players?
Have I just wasted £50?
It appears that it will only output a text file if its contents complies fully with the ECF grading submission rules. I am not a registered grader and do not have the means to register new players which UTU Swiss identifies as data errors.
Has anyone else any experience of UTU Swiss and got to output anything useful that can be sent to an ECF grader when the tournament includes unregistered players?
Have I just wasted £50?
-
- Posts: 21301
- Joined: Tue Apr 15, 2008 2:51 pm
Re: Pairing Software and ECF Grading Submission File
I would have thought you have to work with the local grader to get codes for new players. The players might not be as new as you think and I would strongly suspect misidentification of players is the cause when people moan that their grades are incorrect.Michael Flatt wrote: It appears that it will only output a text file if its contents complies fully with the ECF grading submission rules. I am not a registered grader and do not have the means to register new players which UTU Swiss identifies as data errors.
If UTU refuses to output invalid files, that's a valuable check because it means the ECF system doesn't have to reject them.
-
- Posts: 1235
- Joined: Tue Jul 02, 2013 7:36 am
- Location: Hertfordshire
Re: Pairing Software and ECF Grading Submission File
I wanted to submit a file of the correct format containing the tournament results to the county grader to check the player details and register any new players. By providing data in the correct format I was hoping to save the grader time and effort.Roger de Coverly wrote:If UTU refuses to output invalid files, that's a valuable check because it means the ECF system doesn't have to reject them.
The alternative is to cobble something together on a spreadsheet which is more prone to data errors.
How do other organisers tackle this problem?
-
- Posts: 382
- Joined: Fri Nov 21, 2008 7:11 pm
Re: Pairing Software and ECF Grading Submission File
Are you using the ECF Masterlist? That would have codes already set up for players that may not be graded but may not be new either (eg. only played the odd game).
My memory is a bit hazy on the specifics but when I used to grade the Richmond Rapidplay tournaments, there was a separate checker program that the ECF supplied, Tournament Director's (as it was named then) check wasn't always reliable enough.
With regard to setting up new players, only if nothing was found in the Masterlist would I then set up a new player - I didn't need to generate a code, just input as much information as I could, so that they could easily be identified as a unique individual. The code was then generated by the ECF / Richard Haddrell's system.
My memory is a bit hazy on the specifics but when I used to grade the Richmond Rapidplay tournaments, there was a separate checker program that the ECF supplied, Tournament Director's (as it was named then) check wasn't always reliable enough.
With regard to setting up new players, only if nothing was found in the Masterlist would I then set up a new player - I didn't need to generate a code, just input as much information as I could, so that they could easily be identified as a unique individual. The code was then generated by the ECF / Richard Haddrell's system.
-
- Posts: 1235
- Joined: Tue Jul 02, 2013 7:36 am
- Location: Hertfordshire
Re: Pairing Software and ECF Grading Submission File
I don't have access to the Master List just the one that can be downloaded from the website grading page.
I originally contacted Richard Haddrell and he gave me the choice of becoming a registered grader and be supplied with all the appropriate software or submit results to the local grader.
I opted to submit results to the local grader to check. I bought the licence to UTU Swiss on the basis that it would format and output data in the required format. I hadn't expected to become a registered grader to use it.
I originally contacted Richard Haddrell and he gave me the choice of becoming a registered grader and be supplied with all the appropriate software or submit results to the local grader.
I opted to submit results to the local grader to check. I bought the licence to UTU Swiss on the basis that it would format and output data in the required format. I hadn't expected to become a registered grader to use it.
-
- Posts: 21301
- Joined: Tue Apr 15, 2008 2:51 pm
Re: Pairing Software and ECF Grading Submission File
I would have thought you would register new players before the start of the tournament or at the latest before attempting to submit a grading file.Michael Flatt wrote: I wanted to submit a file of the correct format containing the tournament results to the county grader to check the player details and register any new players. By providing data in the correct format I was hoping to save the grader time and effort.
I don't expect you are prevented from running the tournament, just generating an output file in a specialist format. You could always just send the crosstable to the local grader.
-
- Posts: 1235
- Joined: Tue Jul 02, 2013 7:36 am
- Location: Hertfordshire
Re: Pairing Software and ECF Grading Submission File
Running the tournament is not the problem. I merely want to submit the results to the grader for grading.Roger de Coverly wrote: I don't expect you are prevented from running the tournament, just generating an output file in a specialist format. You could always just send the crosstable to the local grader.
I have not found a means of outputting standings and cross-tables in any machine readable files. I don't see why the grader should have to accept paper copies. There should a simple means of passing the results in electronic form.
As I said previously I wanted to be as helpful as possible to the grader and save him unnecessary work. That is why I bought the licence for UTU Swiss. It is not the same product as Tournament Director.
Has any other organiser been able to use UTU Swiss to output ECF submission files?
-
- Posts: 21301
- Joined: Tue Apr 15, 2008 2:51 pm
Re: Pairing Software and ECF Grading Submission File
Print to file ? That must be how the webmasters get their data, as you frequently see Tournament Director output on websites.Michael Flatt wrote: I have not found a means of outputting standings and cross-tables in any machine readable files
-
- Posts: 1235
- Joined: Tue Jul 02, 2013 7:36 am
- Location: Hertfordshire
Re: Pairing Software and ECF Grading Submission File
UTU Swiss has very few options. Print to file does not appear on any menu I have seen.Roger de Coverly wrote:Print to file ? That must be how the webmasters get their data, as you frequently see Tournament Director output on websites.
The only option is to submit to the dedicated Results website.
The Program User is very limited in what he is allowed to do.
I can view the submission file in preview but it is protected against copying and pasting to a text file. I would prefer that it output the text file with warning messages that can be ignored or deleted.
Currently, there is no means to access the data I want in a form that that I could submit to the grader.
-
- Posts: 2151
- Joined: Thu May 15, 2008 1:37 am
- Contact:
Re: Pairing Software and ECF Grading Submission File
It's not necessary to register new players in advance of submitting results for grading and I'm not even sure this is now possible. New player codes will be assigned automatically on submission if necessary. I'm sure Richard Haddrell ([email protected]) will say...Roger de Coverly wrote:I would have thought you would register new players before the start of the tournament or at the latest before attempting to submit a grading file.Michael Flatt wrote: I wanted to submit a file of the correct format containing the tournament results to the county grader to check the player details and register any new players. By providing data in the correct format I was hoping to save the grader time and effort.
I don't expect you are prevented from running the tournament, just generating an output file in a specialist format. You could always just send the crosstable to the local grader.
I would really recommend signing up as a local "grader" (aka Results Officer) and getting hold of the ECF player list which can then be loaded into UTU Swiss. Though it sounds as though Michael may be too late for this.
I used the new UTU Swiss software a few weeks ago and hit a few snags, one of which, if I recall, concerned a new player. I think I may have ended up copy-and-pasting text from the 'Submission File' tab into a file and then checking it with the Result File Checker provided to Results Officers.
Michael, have you contacted the maker of UTU Swiss for advice?
-
- Posts: 2151
- Joined: Thu May 15, 2008 1:37 am
- Contact:
Re: Pairing Software and ECF Grading Submission File
I was able to use Ctrl-A (select all) and Ctrl-C (copy to the Clipboard).Michael Flatt wrote:I can view the submission file in preview but it is protected against copying and pasting to a text file.
-
- Posts: 1235
- Joined: Tue Jul 02, 2013 7:36 am
- Location: Hertfordshire
Re: Pairing Software and ECF Grading Submission File
I have contacted Neil Hayward and he advises that UTU Swiss will only output a file that fully complies with the ECF grading submission rules. He offers no work around.Angus French wrote:Roger de Coverly wrote:Michael, have you contacted the maker of UTU Swiss for advice?
I have tried to copy from the preview window of the submission file but it is protected against copying.
I would prefer that it output a text file with error messages that can be ignored or deleted.
Knowing what I know now I would never have used it. Totally user unfriendly.
I will try your suggestion, Angus.
-
- Posts: 1235
- Joined: Tue Jul 02, 2013 7:36 am
- Location: Hertfordshire
Re: Pairing Software and ECF Grading Submission File
Fantastic, Angus. That is the solution.Angus French wrote:I was able to use Ctrl-A (select all) and Ctrl-C (copy to the Clipboard).Michael Flatt wrote:I can view the submission file in preview but it is protected against copying and pasting to a text file.
Thank you very much.
It demonstrates that it pays to talk!
- Adam Raoof
- Posts: 2720
- Joined: Sat Oct 04, 2008 4:16 pm
- Location: NW4 4UY
- Contact:
Re: Pairing Software and ECF Grading Submission File
Michael, contact me directly if you need a grader.
One thing which works for me when I get this problem with Swiss Master, which won't produce FIDE rating crosstables unless everyone has a FIDE ID, or date of birth, is to make sure that all the fields have something entered.
In my case a fake DOB or an ECF code instead of a FIDE ID works fine. I can then run the resulting file through the checker to get a legitimate ECF grading file. I just have to remember to delete the fake DOBs!
In your case try using FIDE ID numbers for new players or those without ECF codes. Or make them up!
Can you narrow down your definition of 'data errors'? Will UTC identify what they are in a separate file you can read and copy here?
One thing which works for me when I get this problem with Swiss Master, which won't produce FIDE rating crosstables unless everyone has a FIDE ID, or date of birth, is to make sure that all the fields have something entered.
In my case a fake DOB or an ECF code instead of a FIDE ID works fine. I can then run the resulting file through the checker to get a legitimate ECF grading file. I just have to remember to delete the fake DOBs!
In your case try using FIDE ID numbers for new players or those without ECF codes. Or make them up!
Can you narrow down your definition of 'data errors'? Will UTC identify what they are in a separate file you can read and copy here?
Last edited by Adam Raoof on Thu Oct 09, 2014 11:30 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Adam Raoof IA, IO
Chess England Events - https://chessengland.com/
The Chess Circuit - https://chesscircuit.substack.com/
Don’t stop playing chess!
Chess England Events - https://chessengland.com/
The Chess Circuit - https://chesscircuit.substack.com/
Don’t stop playing chess!
-
- Posts: 3551
- Joined: Wed Jul 02, 2008 4:31 pm
- Location: Awbridge, Hampshire
Re: Pairing Software and ECF Grading Submission File
Michael Flatt wrote:I have just bought a licence for UTU Swiss, the rebadged version of Tournament Director, on the basis that it promises to do pairings for tournaments and generate ECF grading submission files.
It appears that it will only output a text file if its contents complies fully with the ECF grading submission rules. I am not a registered grader and do not have the means to register new players which UTU Swiss identifies as data errors.
If the software claims to fully comply with the ECF grading submission rules, but will not work with new players (by which I assume you mean those without an existing grading code) then it is faulty. There is no ECF requirement for a new player to have a grading code prior to submission of results. The player is allocated one following submission of their first results.Michael Flatt wrote:I have contacted Neil Hayward and he advises that UTU Swiss will only output a file that fully complies with the ECF grading submission rules.
A workaround, while you are waiting for the software to be fixed, might be to make up a grading code for the new player in UTU Swiss, then, once it has generated the ECF grading submission text file, edit the file to remove it.