ECF Elections

[Roger de Coverly]

Material has started to appear about the ECF AGM.

http://www.englishchess.org.uk/nominati ... ons-update

FIDE Delegate is a popular job, with no fewer than three candidates announced.

Lara Barnes
Malcolm Pein
Stewart Reuben

No doubt they will tell the voting membership and the world in general where they think the ECF should stand with regard to the Life Presidency. Malcolm publishes a magazine which in tone and content is hostile to the present FIDE President.

[Paolo Casaschi]

No doubt they will tell the voting membership and the world in general where they think the ECF should stand with regard to the Life Presidency.

Hopefully they'll also explain what else they intend to do to within FIDE to address issues of ECF members. If plotting against KI is the only activity, the ECF might just wait three years before appointing a new FIDE delegate and save on expenses.

[Jonathan Rogers]

It's a touch ludicrous that this position should be so hotly contested when in fact almost anyone can be asked by the Board to stand in as and when the occasion demands. I fear it also says much about the continued problems within the ECF - peeople are prepared to help out the institution in various ways but not to the extent of joining the Board.

[Roger de Coverly]

There is a draft paper on the ECF website about the ECF's future relationship with FIDE.

http://www.englishchess.org.uk/Forum/vi ... ?f=7&t=168

It remains to be seen whether the candidates in the three way election will all share the same views or whether it will become a proxy for a referendum on policy.

A reasonable number of voting members probably have little interest in FIDE matters, provided FIDE keeps its nose out.

[Carl Hibbard]

There are a few new postings over there after being silent for a week or so, all worth a gander.

[JustinHorton]

I wonder why they stopped telling us the day of the week? Did it fall under a confidentiality clause?

[Carl Hibbard]

Traci Whitfield has now been nominated for the Junior Chess position.

[benedgell]

Only one NED candidate?

[Peter D Williams]

Traci Whitfield has now been nominated for the Junior Chess position.

Is this person the parent or a family member of Craig Whitfield? http://ratings.fide.com/card.phtml?event=415073

[Michael Flatt]

Traci Whitfield has now been nominated for the Junior Chess position.

Is this person the parent or a family member of Craig Whitfield? http://ratings.fide.com/card.phtml?event=415073

I don't know. But Traci is deeply involved with the Staffordshire and English Primary Schools Chess Association (EPSCA). [Julian Clissold is EPSCA chairman.] Traci is very well known as an Organiser in the world of Junior Chess.

[Stewart Reuben]

Jonathan Rogers
You are not correct in your statement about people able to stand in in place of the FIDE Delegate. See
http://www.fide.com/component/handbook/ ... w=category
Generally speaking only the FIDE Delegate can be the delegate. If a proxy is used, then that has to be a delegate of a different federation.

I am sad if you think I have not been prepared to be a member of the Board. Over the years I have held 6 different Board positions, one of them for 17 years.

[Jonathan Rogers]

Jonathan Rogers
You are not correct in your statement about people able to stand in in place of the FIDE Delegate. See
http://www.fide.com/component/handbook/ ... w=category
Generally speaking only the FIDE Delegate can be the delegate. If a proxy is used, then that has to be a delegate of a different federation.

I am surprised to learn that; though surely it was natural to assume that there would be more flexibility. Thanks for the correction.

I am sad if you think I have not been prepared to be a member of the Board. Over the years I have held 6 different Board positions, one of them for 17 years.

[/quote][/quote]

No offence intended, Stewart. But the fact that you have done so much in the past goes both ways - you might have thought you had done enough already!

Besides which, it's not all about you; there are three candidates. I still think it is notable that a non-Board position is apparently to be the only contested one.

[NickFaulks]

Jonathan Rogers
You are not correct in your statement about people able to stand in in place of the FIDE Delegate.

I thought Jonathan's point was the that post of Delegate could be held by, for instance, the President until that person was required to do something, at which point he could resign and someone could be appointed for that purpose. That may well conflict with the current ECF Statutes, but would be fine with FIDE. It doesn't seem like the worst way of doing things.

[Roger de Coverly]

You are not correct in your statement about people able to stand in in place of the FIDE Delegate.

I thought the ECF could appoint a substitute. That was the proposition put to the voting membership regarding Nigel's substitution by Andrew Paulson.

The FIDE Delegate being elected alongside the Board is an ECF practice as opposed to a FIDE requirement. A bigger problem, it seems to me, could be the role of the "President" which is an office appearing several times in the FIDE Statutes. What if the ECF only has an "Honorary President" with the CEO the man in charge?

[Stewart Reuben]

Roger. Andrew Paulson was being proposed to substitute Nigel Short in the ECU Election. That organisation has its own statutes. I haven't bothered to read them.
They didn't seem to have a regulation that speakers had to be audible at the afternoon session of the ECU. In fact it was fairly common in the Commissions as well that the top table spoke only to each other, even if there was an audience of perhaps 20+ people. That criticism did not apply in the Rules or Qualification Commissions.
The African Chess Union meeting apparently descended into farce.