Revised Tournament Rating Limits ?

General discussions about ratings.
Sean Hewitt

Re: Revised Tournament Rating Limits ?

Post by Sean Hewitt » Fri Oct 17, 2008 5:50 pm

Paul Stimpson wrote:
the tournament limits have not always been the same.
I need to get more examples but a quick look at Chess Magazine 1988 Remploy Congress

Minor - u110
Major - u160

Looking at Huddersfield Congress - 2008

Minor - u100
Major - u160

Ilford Congress - 2007

Minor - u120
Major - u160

This doesn't exactly back up your claim I'm afraid.
You're using one tournament (Remploy 1988) to make a case?! Come on!

However, if you want to play that game :-

Lutterworth Minor 1984 U125

Leicester Minor 1983 U120.

Almost all minors (or whatever they get called these days) are U100 or less. A quick look at the ECF calendar for Oct and Nov reveals

Leicester Oct 2008 U100
Birmingham RP Oct 2008 U90
Oxford RP Oct 2008 U100
Caterham Oct 2008 U100
Scarborough Oct 2008 U95
Hull Nov 2008 U95
Milton Keynes Nov 2008 U100
Bolton RP Nov 2008 U120
Preston Nov 2008 U100
Torbay Nov 2008 U100
British RP Nov 2008 U101

Backs up my case exactly I would have said!

Paul Stimpson
Posts: 109
Joined: Mon Feb 25, 2008 10:52 pm
Location: Essex

Re: Revised Tournament Rating Limits ?

Post by Paul Stimpson » Fri Oct 17, 2008 11:03 pm

You're using one tournament (Remploy 1988) to make a case?! Come on!

However, if you want to play that game :-
I'm not playing a game I did say I only had access to one example, but I have more now...

Digging out ChessMoves 1991 the following examples

South Herts Open, u176, u150, u130, u106
Chester Open, u160, u125, u100
Calderdale Open, u160, u135, u110
Scunthorpe Open, u150, u110
Warrington Open, u166, u130, u100
Norfolk Open, u161, u131, u101

1990

Liverpool Open, u151, u111
Stevenage Open, u156, u125, u90
Torbay Open, u156, u126, u101
Holy Crosss Open, u157, u132, u101

Plenty of counter evidence there then!

10 events from around 18 years ago that are practically matching grading limit sections of today!

Oh and Chorley 2005 and 2006 Minor was u120 yet oddly 1999 minor was u110?