I recently came to know that the selection to European schools team is predominantly decided in the UKCC and only 20% of the team from non-UKCC. Apparently this has been a policy/board decision. It is very obvious this is
1. a single-point-failure situation, therefore inherently unfair.
2. a box ticking exercise, the polar opposite of subjectivity in selection.
Could any one explain how such a draconian policy was accepted by the board?
Is there not a move to make this selection more fair ?
Selection to European schools
-
- Posts: 21301
- Joined: Tue Apr 15, 2008 2:51 pm
Re: selection to European schools
The rules are hereRad Kadengal wrote: Could any one explain how such a draconian policy was accepted by the board?
Is there not a move to make this selection more fair ?
http://englishchess.org.uk/Juniors/play ... on-policy/
The event referred to appear to be this
European Schools Individual Championship, Kavala, Greece 16-27 June 2014
and the ECF categorise them as
which is a polite way of saying that it's for the reserve squad, those without yet the strength or experience to be selected for the world or European championships.DEVELOPMENTAL CHAMPIONSHIPS
These events offer a great experience in terms of gaining international experience and being part of an England squad with access to coaching from some of England’s leading players.
So I suppose the logic behind reserving places for those who do well in the UKCC is that it encourages participation in that event by awarding extra "prizes".
There's a long history of controversy about the balance in Junior Selection as to whether to only send the elite or invite wider participation. It isn't helped that at a world standard, very few young English players are anywhere near good enough to be challenging to win the events.
-
- Posts: 7173
- Joined: Tue Dec 20, 2011 8:13 am
Re: selection to European schools
Dear Rad,Rad Kadengal wrote:I recently came to know that the selection to European schools team is predominantly decided in the UKCC and only 20% of the team from non-UKCC. Apparently this has been a policy/board decision. It is very obvious this is
1. a single-point-failure situation, therefore inherently unfair.
2. a box ticking exercise, the polar opposite of subjectivity in selection.
Could any one explain how such a draconian policy was accepted by the board?
Is there not a move to make this selection more fair ?
There isn't anything more I can add to our exchange of e-mails on this subject. I inherited 116 nominations from the UKCC and did my best to honour as many of those as I could. I didn't feel it was fair to invite additional players when I couldn't accommodate all of the nominees at this particular event. As we've already discussed though there will be opportunities for your son in the future and I look forward to him being part of the squad at subsequent events.
Yours sincerely,
Lawrence Cooper
Director of Junior Chess & Education
English Chess Federation
-
- Posts: 23
- Joined: Sun Mar 23, 2014 5:07 pm
Re: Selection to European schools
Dear Lawrence
FYI, I use forum discussions only for matters of 'public interest' (never for individual matters) and would like to keep it that way.
The 'public interest' test is supported by Roger's reply that there is indeed a long history of controversy in this area, that hasn't helped English Chess.
Why did come to be like that? What are we going to do about it ? How are we going to improve the situation ?
I suppose there isn't anything stopping us having an open debate on that?
FYI, I use forum discussions only for matters of 'public interest' (never for individual matters) and would like to keep it that way.
The 'public interest' test is supported by Roger's reply that there is indeed a long history of controversy in this area, that hasn't helped English Chess.
Why did come to be like that? What are we going to do about it ? How are we going to improve the situation ?
I suppose there isn't anything stopping us having an open debate on that?
-
- Posts: 21301
- Joined: Tue Apr 15, 2008 2:51 pm
Re: Selection to European schools
I was referring to an era where contenders for selection at World and European level were expected to waste their weekends playing 5 round G/75 Swiss events against other contenders.Rad Kadengal wrote: The 'public interest' test is supported by Roger's reply that there is indeed a long history of controversy in this area, that hasn't helped English Chess
The latest accounts reveal a massive increase in ECF spending on International Junior events, financed by parents. This has mostly gone in the direction of the "Schools" events. I accept the point that you should limit the size of the squad, as otherwise you just get squad members playing one another.
Chess tourism is well established in Greece and to a lesser extent at an individual level Turkey, so there should be a reasonable choice of Open events in agreeable hotels on attractive islands or at popular resorts. Spain, Italy, France, Holland and Germany also have a wide selection of summer tournaments.
I would have thought an unofficial party quite possible. Put together a small group of families willing to travel to an attractive tournament and arrange for an experienced player or coach to play there or visit there as well. Come up with some deal where he or she spends some time on training.
-
- Posts: 4818
- Joined: Tue Apr 17, 2007 1:13 am
- Location: Bideford
Re: Selection to European schools
I could do this.Roger de Coverly wrote: I would have thought an unofficial party quite possible. Put together a small group of families willing to travel to an attractive tournament and arrange for an experienced player or coach to play there or visit there as well. Come up with some deal where he or she spends some time on training.
-
- Posts: 2720
- Joined: Sat Oct 04, 2008 4:16 pm
- Location: NW4 4UY
Re: Selection to European schools
Although I have difficulty in pinning down any 'official' half term dates (which would be the ideal time to have a coaching event), I've been thinking of offering something like this for a while. The JETS scheme in Australia and the US is particularly popular, a good model, and a party could piggy back onto a cheap event such as Hampstead (as it used to be, at UCS school with IMs and GMs playing) or Golders Green (where it is over a Bank Holiday so we have an Open section), or even a residential overseas tournament such as Malta rating / IM tournament coming up in May with little difficulty. That way we get a titled player or two to coach, and plenty of opportunities for the players to improve their rating.
Adam Raoof IA, IO
Chess England Events - https://chessengland.com/
The Chess Circuit - https://chesscircuit.substack.com/
Don’t stop playing chess!
Chess England Events - https://chessengland.com/
The Chess Circuit - https://chesscircuit.substack.com/
Don’t stop playing chess!