Christmas means is that, in our own bizarrely human way, we are caught up in an outbreak of mattering, and that always matters.
I suspect there's more than a smattering of mattering in his book.
Christmas means is that, in our own bizarrely human way, we are caught up in an outbreak of mattering, and that always matters.
There's bound to be some chess in there - another of Justin H's stomping grounds.A revamp for The London Review of Books, which is celebrating its 40th birthday by putting its entire archive of 17,500 articles online for free until mid-January as part of a digital revamp. Co-founder and editor Mary-Kay Wilmers said: “Generally, I don’t like reading pieces online but even I would consider doing so on our new website.” A glowing endorsement. (Londoner's Diary, ES 18/12/2019)
andJonathan Rowson @Jonathan_Rowson
Dec 21
A negative review!
Some factual errors already spotted. All survived copyediting & fact checking -it happens.
But single lines presented incredulously out of context & no curiosity towards author intent.
It's a curmudgeonly hatchet job, unworthy of @TheTLS
Am I being naive in thinking that authors themselves should check their facts before putting them into a final draft - if not the first?Jonathan Rowson @Jonathan_Rowson
Dec 21
The book went through several edits, a final copy edit and a fact checker. Any errors that remain are my responsibility, but I’m actually *not* embarrassed by them, because- like chess(!)- some are inevitable, and I did everything I could to avoid them.
There's a reason for this, which is that no intent was discernable. The reason for that is that Rowson can rarely keep to the point for more than a couple of paragraphs at a time, or (as I say in the review) bother to back up any observation he makes with anything so vulgar as a supporting argument.Jonathan Rowson @Jonathan_Rowson.
no curiosity towards author intent
I was by the way, genuinely disappointed with the false quotations. The man's got more than one degree, he's written a PhD thesis (incidentally, had I had more room I would have quoted his own commentary on that thesis) and he really ought to know better than to just throw in unsourced quotations from famous people without checking them. It's lazy and it's asking for trouble.Gerard Killoran wrote: ↑Mon Dec 23, 2019 6:09 pmAm I being naive in thinking that authors themselves should check their facts before putting them into a final draft - if not the first?
I can imagineStewart Reuben wrote: ↑Fri Dec 27, 2019 12:50 am
The only flaw in the evening was that several of the speeches, by very distinguished guests, many with honours, were much too long.
If think I get a minor role in the book for making JR cry, so I’m prepared to overlook any perceived deficiencies! Although I’m not sure I’m quite suited to the role of English oppressor crushing Scottish dreams, so I would just put it down to being a ridiculous swindler.Kevin Thurlow wrote: ↑Thu Dec 19, 2019 12:12 pm"The meaning doesn’t matter if it’s only idle chatter of a transcendental kind!"
WS Gilbert
I may be getting the book in question for Christmas. At first Justin's review alarmed me, but then I thought it makes the book sound even more intriguing. The reviews released either by the publishers or Waterstones were a bit more upbeat...