Good afternoon,
A few quick thoughts if I may ...
David Robertson wrote:I doubt Jonathan Bryant knew Nigel's strength of feeling on the matter because I very much doubt he'd have intended gratuitous offensive.
Indeed. I did not intend
any offence, gratuitous or otherwise. You are correct in your guess that I didn't know Nigel's 'strength of feeling' about the nickname I used. Actually, I didn't know he had any feelings about it at all.
David Robertson wrote:JB may not even know the context of the appellation.
I know, as I think many folk do, that it's a contraction of an anagram of "Nigel Short". Beyond that, I was only vaguely aware (and remain so).
David Robertson wrote:
Nigel regards it as offensive. Hence, use the term wittingly only if you intend offense. In that case, don't come over all faint when he defends himself.
Personally, I'd write the second sentence as something like,
"Hence, use the term wittingly only with the awareness that offence will be taken." The first and third I'd leave as they are.
Geoff Chandler wrote:Also cannot see why Carl is so upset over F**K.
F**K doesn't bother me in the slightest, but I think it's about context. I've used the f-word on the blog before and would be happy to again, but I think a forum such as this is a bit different.
Actually, I once wrote out f--k in a post assuming that the profanity blocker would kick in with the asterisks but it didn't. I noticed straight away and edited my post at once, but even though it only took seconds somebody had already noticed and been upset by it. That was fair enough, I think.
Finally,
Nigel Short wrote:Please show a modicum of respect.
I think I do have a due respect for your achievements at the chess board. A few days before your message I'd posted
this, for example (you have to scroll to the 10th post down).
I used a nickname for you which I believed - and I think I had good reason to believe - was widely used and was intended as an affectionate term rather than something impolite. While I think it quite reasonable that you point out that this was a misunderstanding on my part, I'm not at all sure that it's reasonable to assume that my use of the nickname was somehow a demonstration of a lack of respect.
Or, to put it another way, I'm not sure many people would consider "N____r" to be a synonym for "f--k face". If you do then fair enough, but I don't see how I can be expected to have known that before you said so.