Remembering Alexander McDonnell (22-iv-1798 14-ix-1835)

Historical knowledge and information regarding our great game.
User avatar
Gerard Killoran
Posts: 542
Joined: Sun Oct 04, 2009 11:51 am

Re: Remembering Alexander McDonnell (22-iv-1798 14-ix-1835)

Post by Gerard Killoran » Mon Nov 02, 2020 4:53 pm

Therefore, any author nowadays deciding to list pages of amendments to the 1987 McFarland edition needs to find out which amendments Gaige himself made in 1994, and to give him due credit.
Not if the 1994 edition was 'privately circulated' and 'exceptionally scarce'. If he wanted 'due credit' perhaps he should have made it available to people who had bought his book, rather than just a circle of friends so small, it didn't even include his publishers.
The "point", as Gerard puts it, was made clear by Edward Winter in his article, and is concerned with preserving respect for Gaige's work, even though it wasn't published.
Obviously 'respect' is very important to Edward Winter.

'But you don't ask with respect. You don't offer friendship. You don't even think to call me Godfather.'

Post Reply