A question about noise during a match
-
- Posts: 19
- Joined: Tue Nov 03, 2009 9:03 am
A question about noise during a match
Hi,
I'm new to the forum and returning to chess club play. The reason I stopped playing club matches was that I had to forfeit a game as my insulin pump beeped an alarm during the game. Is that standard? As I need the pump for medical reasons, it's not like a mobile phone, though that is the argument my opponent made and the arbiter agreed with. I am concerned that this could happen again, so before I agree to play on a team, I'd like to know what the policy is.
dave
I'm new to the forum and returning to chess club play. The reason I stopped playing club matches was that I had to forfeit a game as my insulin pump beeped an alarm during the game. Is that standard? As I need the pump for medical reasons, it's not like a mobile phone, though that is the argument my opponent made and the arbiter agreed with. I am concerned that this could happen again, so before I agree to play on a team, I'd like to know what the policy is.
dave
-
- Posts: 585
- Joined: Tue Apr 10, 2007 3:12 pm
- Location: Darlington
Re: A question about noise during a match
Sorry Dave that is some real bs that happened to you no that should not be standard.It might be best for you to imform the opposing captain of your medical condition and your pump.I would dp the same if i was playing a congress i would explain to the arbiter.You should never be penalised for a medical condition.
I have a very serious arthritic illness that meens i have to get up and walk around quite a lot when i play.Also it a good job drug teasting does not happen at local league or congress level or i would be screwed the amount of morphine i am on lol.
I have a very serious arthritic illness that meens i have to get up and walk around quite a lot when i play.Also it a good job drug teasting does not happen at local league or congress level or i would be screwed the amount of morphine i am on lol.
I am speaking here for myself and not the NCCU which i am now president of
-
- Posts: 2720
- Joined: Sat Oct 04, 2008 4:16 pm
- Location: NW4 4UY
Re: A question about noise during a match
What match was this?
What League was it played in?
Who were the teams?
Who was the arbiter?
Did you appeal?
What League was it played in?
Who were the teams?
Who was the arbiter?
Did you appeal?
Adam Raoof IA, IO
Chess England Events - https://chessengland.com/
The Chess Circuit - https://chesscircuit.substack.com/
Don’t stop playing chess!
Chess England Events - https://chessengland.com/
The Chess Circuit - https://chesscircuit.substack.com/
Don’t stop playing chess!
-
- Posts: 4829
- Joined: Tue Apr 17, 2007 1:13 am
- Location: Bideford
Re: A question about noise during a match
The exact text of the mobile phone rule is as follows (emphasis mine):
Your insulin beeper is not a means of communication, so this law does not apply to it. It may, on the other hand, be subject to this law:FIDE Laws Of Chess wrote:12.3b Without the permission of the arbiter a player is forbidden to have a mobile phone or other electronic means of communication in the playing venue, unless they are completely switched off. If any such device produces a sound, the player shall lose the game. The opponent shall win. However, if the opponent cannot win the game by any series of legal moves, his score shall be a draw.
Now 12.6 is one of those rules where the punishment for an offence is up to the discretion of the arbiter. My take on this is that very few arbiters would default you if they knew beforehand that the device was an insulin beeper, so your best policy is to tell the arbiter before the game that you've got one.FIDE Laws Of Chess wrote:12.6 It is forbidden to distract or annoy the opponent in any manner whatsoever. This includes unreasonable claims, unreasonable offers of a draw or the introduction of a source of noise into the playing area.
-
- Posts: 246
- Joined: Thu Aug 20, 2009 10:53 pm
Re: A question about noise during a match
That is absolutely appalling, the player and arbiter should hang their heads in shame.Dave Roberts wrote:The reason I stopped playing club matches was that I had to forfeit a game as my insulin pump beeped an alarm during the game. ... that is the argument my opponent made and the arbiter agreed with.
Discrimination on the grounds of disability (either directly or indirectly) should have no place in chess and when it arises, it should be dealt with severely.
I hope that someone from the ECF can say something formally.
Jack rightly mentions rule 12.6, my personal feeling is that the noise from an insulin alarm is no more of a burden than the noise a blind player might make when dictating his moves into his portable recording device.
Chess Amateur.
-
- Posts: 19
- Joined: Tue Nov 03, 2009 9:03 am
Re: A question about noise during a match
Thanks a lot for the support. This happened about 10 years ago in Scotland - I was playing for the Bon Accord Chess club in Aberdeen. The arbiter's name was John something or other. I should have appealed, but decided not to. I was pretty upset about it at the time, as I felt it was blatant discrimination and was very surprised others didn't see it that way.
I feel better about returning to the world of organised chess - I've been playing friendlies at a club here in Coventry and was asked if I'd like to play for a team. I'll agree now!
Thanks again for all of your responses!
dave
I feel better about returning to the world of organised chess - I've been playing friendlies at a club here in Coventry and was asked if I'd like to play for a team. I'll agree now!
Thanks again for all of your responses!
dave
-
- Posts: 3735
- Joined: Thu Apr 12, 2007 3:01 pm
- Location: Hayes (Middx)
Re: A question about noise during a match
That is a terrible story. I would agree that both the opponent and the arbiter should hang their heads in shame if what you say is true. I would be happy to play you, or have you in the same team. Good luck.
FIDE Arbiter, FIDE Instructor
Richmond Junior Chess Club
Fulham Junior Chess Club
ECF Games Played Abroad Administrator
Richmond Junior Chess Club
Fulham Junior Chess Club
ECF Games Played Abroad Administrator
-
- Posts: 21322
- Joined: Tue Apr 15, 2008 2:51 pm
Re: A question about noise during a match
The specific mobile phone rule didn't come in until 2005. Before that, it would perhaps have been a local interpretation or a more general "distract the opponent" penalty. Either way it lacks justification.Dave Roberts wrote:Thanks a lot for the support. This happened about 10 years ago in Scotland - I was playing for the Bon Accord Chess club in Aberdeen.
There's also a forum at Chess Scotland www.chessscotland.com. The Scottish forum is "official" though.
-
- Posts: 1420
- Joined: Fri Jun 01, 2007 6:31 pm
Re: A question about noise during a match
If this happened 10 years ago the arbiter's decision is worse than it appears. The rule quoted by Jack - 12.6 was 12.5 in 1997 - 2001 and did not make specific mention of noise. At that time the rule said:-Dave Roberts wrote:Thanks a lot for the support. This happened about 10 years ago in Scotland
12.5. It is forbidden to distract or annoy the opponent in any manner whatsoever; this includes the persistent offer of a draw.
-
- Posts: 19
- Joined: Tue Nov 03, 2009 9:03 am
Re: A question about noise during a match
Thanks - but as I'm in England now this forum is fine. My opponent claimed it was a distraction and, as the penalty at the time (locally possibly) for mobile phones was forfeiting the game, the arbiter gave my opponent the game. My concern was, before I start playing here, that a similar interpretation might happen. I can avoid some of the alarms the pump gives but not all of them.Roger de Coverly wrote:The specific mobile phone rule didn't come in until 2005. Before that, it would perhaps have been a local interpretation or a more general "distract the opponent" penalty. Either way it lacks justification.Dave Roberts wrote:Thanks a lot for the support. This happened about 10 years ago in Scotland - I was playing for the Bon Accord Chess club in Aberdeen.
There's also a forum at Chess Scotland http://www.chessscotland.com. The Scottish forum is "official" though.
-
- Posts: 19
- Joined: Tue Nov 03, 2009 9:03 am
Re: A question about noise during a match
It was. I had just started playing for them and was more upset that my team didn't support me. But it was a while ago, so hopefully this time around it will go better!Paul McKeown wrote:That is a terrible story. I would agree that both the opponent and the arbiter should hang their heads in shame if what you say is true. I would be happy to play you, or have you in the same team. Good luck.
If you are ever in the Coventry area - I'd love to meet up for a game!
-
- Posts: 1758
- Joined: Sat Aug 02, 2008 8:52 pm
Re: A question about noise during a match
We do tend to apply the Laws more rigourously north of the border. But this was obviously wrong at the time. It could certainly now be seen as bringing a source of noise into the playing hall and as such Jack is correct in saying that you should inform the arbiter. If this is done then I would doubt very much if any penalty would be given. However if the arbiter is not warned then you may expect some penalty, which I suggest would normally be a warning or slight time penalty. If though it distracted a player in a time scramble the penalty may be more severe.
Since the original incident was 10 years ago I am loathe to approach John Clifford (if indeed it was him) for his account of events.
Since the original incident was 10 years ago I am loathe to approach John Clifford (if indeed it was him) for his account of events.
-
- Posts: 19
- Joined: Tue Nov 03, 2009 9:03 am
Re: A question about noise during a match
Hi Alex,Alex McFarlane wrote:We do tend to apply the Laws more rigourously north of the border. But this was obviously wrong at the time. It could certainly now be seen as bringing a source of noise into the playing hall and as such Jack is correct in saying that you should inform the arbiter. If this is done then I would doubt very much if any penalty would be given. However if the arbiter is not warned then you may expect some penalty, which I suggest would normally be a warning or slight time penalty. If though it distracted a player in a time scramble the penalty may be more severe.
Since the original incident was 10 years ago I am loathe to approach John Clifford (if indeed it was him) for his account of events.
that's very good advice about informing the arbiter - thanks for that. I hadn't considered it, as alarms are very infrequent (once or twice a year). I in no way wanted to dredge up the past, as it was a long time ago, so there is no need to bring it up with John Clifford. I honestly can't remember his last name.
dave
-
- Posts: 19
- Joined: Tue Nov 03, 2009 9:03 am
Re: A question about noise during a match
Hi,
just wanted to thank everyone again for their input. I've decided to play on a team, which is starting next week. And I've taken the advice to let the arbiter know about the pump.
Wishing you all a very good new year!
dave roberts
just wanted to thank everyone again for their input. I've decided to play on a team, which is starting next week. And I've taken the advice to let the arbiter know about the pump.
Wishing you all a very good new year!
dave roberts
-
- Posts: 912
- Joined: Fri Nov 23, 2007 3:46 pm
Re: A question about noise during a match
In my opinion even though it is very sensible to inform the arbiter in advance, even if that is not done I would consider it inappropriate in the circumstances to award any penalty other than possibly time added to the opponent if they have been distracted, and I suspect that most opponents would object if any other penalty were imposed. It would also be sensible to warn your opponent though that there is a slight chance they may hear a beep.
If I became aware of a player being defaulted in such circumstances in any tournament I was in, then I would probably withdraw from the tournament in protest. It is like saying any player with a disability is distracting their opponent. I really do not understand the concept of a warning (other than simply to inform the arbiter in future) what do they want you to do turn off the machine?
If I became aware of a player being defaulted in such circumstances in any tournament I was in, then I would probably withdraw from the tournament in protest. It is like saying any player with a disability is distracting their opponent. I really do not understand the concept of a warning (other than simply to inform the arbiter in future) what do they want you to do turn off the machine?