What is a Bona Fide Member of a Chess Club
-
- Posts: 912
- Joined: Fri Nov 23, 2007 3:46 pm
Re: What is a Bona Fide Member of a Chess Club
When any player plays their first match for a club they have joined they could be accused of not being "Bona Fide" member and just being drafted in for that one match particularly if it is a cup match.
If there is no further definition of "Bona Fide" in the context of the competition rules then at some point, someone must make a decision based on how the rules are written and as far as possible with regard to the intention of the rules.
If I was asked to do this, the sort of things I would look at are:
1) Where does the player live and work - is it close to club?
2) Has the person paid membership fees (but may be acceptable even if they hadn't for example the player could have been given free membership if they hold a title)?
3) Has the player played for the club before?
4) is there any other evidence for example emails?
5) The strength of the player - the stronger the player the more likely they have been head hunted for a particular match (but teams do have strong players who play occasionally)
6) The background of the club - has historically a very strong player played for just one important match?
If there is no further definition of "Bona Fide" in the context of the competition rules then at some point, someone must make a decision based on how the rules are written and as far as possible with regard to the intention of the rules.
If I was asked to do this, the sort of things I would look at are:
1) Where does the player live and work - is it close to club?
2) Has the person paid membership fees (but may be acceptable even if they hadn't for example the player could have been given free membership if they hold a title)?
3) Has the player played for the club before?
4) is there any other evidence for example emails?
5) The strength of the player - the stronger the player the more likely they have been head hunted for a particular match (but teams do have strong players who play occasionally)
6) The background of the club - has historically a very strong player played for just one important match?
-
- Posts: 1915
- Joined: Tue Mar 17, 2015 2:44 pm
Re: What is a Bona Fide Member of a Chess Club
It's a well-known concept in legal circles that there are some words - "normal" and "regular" are typical examples - where the meaning can't be pinned down with universal accuracy and that such words have (in the last resort) to be interpreted by judges against the circumstances in which they are used. Much the same situation applies here in that it's impossible to set down a set of rules, attempting to define "member" or "bona fide member", which would be equitable in every conceivable circumstance. So, as with "normal" and "regular", interpretation is needed in each case. Without wishing to seem discourteous, I have to say that those who don't understand this are pursuing a futile argument.
-
- Posts: 45
- Joined: Sun Jul 23, 2017 11:36 pm
Re: What is a Bona Fide Member of a Chess Club
When i tell people nothing to do with chess or the politics of it from all walks they dont the decision.
-
- Posts: 11
- Joined: Thu Sep 06, 2018 10:42 am
Re: What is a Bona Fide Member of a Chess Club
its a simple question Alex
I am asking your opinion
WHEN DOES DAVID BECOME AN BONA FIDE MEMBER OR IS IT NEVER ?
You can put on clever diagram but a simple question deserves an BONA FIDE answer from you
I am asking your opinion
WHEN DOES DAVID BECOME AN BONA FIDE MEMBER OR IS IT NEVER ?
You can put on clever diagram but a simple question deserves an BONA FIDE answer from you
-
- Posts: 9085
- Joined: Sat May 30, 2009 5:18 pm
- Location: Oldbury, Worcestershire
Re: What is a Bona Fide Member of a Chess Club
It is indeed a simple question. It is also an entirely irrelevant one.Trevor Coote wrote: ↑Fri Sep 07, 2018 1:25 pmits a simple question Alex
I am asking your opinion
WHEN DOES DAVID BECOME AN BONA FIDE MEMBER OR IS IT NEVER ?
You can put on clever diagram but a simple question deserves an BONA FIDE answer from you
-
- Posts: 10381
- Joined: Tue Apr 17, 2007 10:12 am
- Location: Bolton, Greater Manchester
Re: What is a Bona Fide Member of a Chess Club
Blimey, is Essex now Surrey in disguise?
Any postings on here represent my personal views
-
- Posts: 10364
- Joined: Mon Aug 04, 2008 10:06 am
- Location: Somewhere you're not
Re: What is a Bona Fide Member of a Chess Club
Still some way to go in that respect I think
"Do you play chess?"
"Yes, but I prefer a game with a better chance of cheating."
lostontime.blogspot.com
"Yes, but I prefer a game with a better chance of cheating."
lostontime.blogspot.com
-
- Posts: 1838
- Joined: Thu Dec 01, 2011 12:16 am
Re: What is a Bona Fide Member of a Chess Club
There has not been such a significant dispute in Surrey for a number of years.
When there was we agreed to do something about it. Change the rules to deal with never having the problem reoccurring.
And that has worked.
Let's put it this way. If I were a member of Writtle, I would not want my club to make such a complaint in the first place. Or if it did to get the controller/appeal committee to rule against Writtle. I certainly would not want to play for my club again.
Generally leagues get themselves wrapped up with rules that does not allow players to move or transfer. Many only make the complaint after they have lost.
I'm wishing for the coming season we have no disputes at all about chess clubs. I blew out a candle on my small dessert thinking about this discussion.
When there was we agreed to do something about it. Change the rules to deal with never having the problem reoccurring.
And that has worked.
Let's put it this way. If I were a member of Writtle, I would not want my club to make such a complaint in the first place. Or if it did to get the controller/appeal committee to rule against Writtle. I certainly would not want to play for my club again.
Generally leagues get themselves wrapped up with rules that does not allow players to move or transfer. Many only make the complaint after they have lost.
I'm wishing for the coming season we have no disputes at all about chess clubs. I blew out a candle on my small dessert thinking about this discussion.
-
- Posts: 11
- Joined: Thu Sep 06, 2018 10:42 am
Re: What is a Bona Fide Member of a Chess Club
To Alex
How can it be an irrelevant question when the whole topic is what is a BONA FIDE member
if You don't know then just be honest and say so
if you do know enlighten the masses with your vast knowledge however irrelevant you feel it maybe
so just one more time
WHEN DOES DAVID BECOME AN BONA FIDE MEMBER OR IS IT NEVER ?
How can it be an irrelevant question when the whole topic is what is a BONA FIDE member
if You don't know then just be honest and say so
if you do know enlighten the masses with your vast knowledge however irrelevant you feel it maybe
so just one more time
WHEN DOES DAVID BECOME AN BONA FIDE MEMBER OR IS IT NEVER ?
-
- Posts: 4828
- Joined: Tue Apr 17, 2007 1:13 am
- Location: Bideford
Re: What is a Bona Fide Member of a Chess Club
Alex is not an official of, or player in, the league in question. Why would he be expected to know what its definition of a bona fide member is?
-
- Posts: 2075
- Joined: Tue Nov 22, 2011 9:23 pm
- Location: Harrogate
Re: What is a Bona Fide Member of a Chess Club
I think the problem is that there are two different matters under discussion here. One is (as the title suggests) what a Bona Fide member actually is in strict application of the term and when somebody might not be a Bona Fide member.
The other question is whether the Essex controller and the appeals committee made the right decision in this particular instance. The diversion of views from people involved with different leagues is not uninteresting but ultimately it is an internal matter for Essex whose officers are (presumably) elected and accountable.
The other question is whether the Essex controller and the appeals committee made the right decision in this particular instance. The diversion of views from people involved with different leagues is not uninteresting but ultimately it is an internal matter for Essex whose officers are (presumably) elected and accountable.
Controller - Yorkshire League
Chairman - Harrogate Chess Club
All views expressed entirely my own
Chairman - Harrogate Chess Club
All views expressed entirely my own
Re: What is a Bona Fide Member of a Chess Club
I SAY, DO WE ALL GET TO PLAY WITH THE FONTSTrevor Coote wrote: ↑Fri Sep 07, 2018 3:50 pmTo Alex
How can it be an irrelevant question when the whole topic is what is a BONA FIDE member
if You don't know then just be honest and say so
if you do know enlighten the masses with your vast knowledge however irrelevant you feel it maybe
so just one more time
WHEN DOES DAVID BECOME AN BONA FIDE MEMBER OR IS IT NEVER ?
-
- Posts: 8838
- Joined: Fri Aug 06, 2010 2:34 am
- Location: London
Re: What is a Bona Fide Member of a Chess Club
I say, can we nitpick grammar as well?
"an bona fide member"??
(Seriously, is some of the ill will here spilling over from the Facebook thread mentioned earlier?)
"an bona fide member"??
(Seriously, is some of the ill will here spilling over from the Facebook thread mentioned earlier?)
-
- Posts: 11
- Joined: Thu Sep 06, 2018 10:42 am
Re: What is a Bona Fide Member of a Chess Club
IM Jack Rudd wrote: ↑Fri Sep 07, 2018 3:52 pmAlex is not an official of, or player in, the league in question. Why would he be expected to know what its definition of a bona fide member is?
Jack
Last time I looked Alex Holowczak was the Director of Home Chess although he has resigned with effect from the 13th October 2018. so as an official of ECF I would of thought he may know the answer
-
- Posts: 8838
- Joined: Fri Aug 06, 2010 2:34 am
- Location: London
Re: What is a Bona Fide Member of a Chess Club
Heh. If you think the different leagues up and down the country would listen to what the Director of Home Chess said... The occupants of that office over the years know better than to get involved in local disputes like that. (They have enough to deal with in the disputes from the competitions they do oversee, such as the Counties Championship [national stages].)