Do you believe in God
-
- Posts: 456
- Joined: Sat Oct 11, 2008 9:56 pm
Re: Do you believe in God
Last one for now...
I knew it wouldn't take too long for Alex H to get stuck in as he just can't seem to resist a good thread (or any thread really)...
I knew it wouldn't take too long for Alex H to get stuck in as he just can't seem to resist a good thread (or any thread really)...
-
- Posts: 3604
- Joined: Fri May 16, 2008 11:54 am
Re: Do you believe in God
YesNick Thomas wrote:There are many things that science cannot yet explain. Your butterfly example is a strange choice as an example. But my rather uninformed attempt is: By Darwinian evolution in gradual increments by means of natural selection over a long period of time.Matthew Turner wrote:Robert Thompson wrote
"1) Why should i believe in something there is no evidence for?"
There are some things that Science cannot explain. How did butterflies evolve? for example. Is it scientific to simply discount the possibly of a creationalist entity?
If you consider the 'multiverse' theories of science which I think most scientists believe in today, then with many many universes to consider isn't it much more likely that in one there exists a supremely powerful entity which one might call God for short?
It is not clear to me how a process of gradual Darwinian Evolution could result in a process of metamorphosis. That almost seems contradictory?
No it is not scientific to discount any possibility but then again no scientist would do that. Science is not by definition dogmatic and scientists are therefore always open to review new evidence and change their view accordingly. What makes you think that most scientists believe in the multiverse theory?
I don't think there is 'multiverse theory' but there a great many theories based around the idea of strings and additional dimensions and the like which would all fall under a multiverse umbrella. I think most scientists would say that one of these theories was the best that we had at present.
Certainly most think it a possibility. What do you mean "one might call god for short"? Are you lumping all sorts of different types of gods into the pot?
-
- Posts: 1071
- Joined: Sat Apr 14, 2007 3:16 pm
- Location: Sutton Coldfield
Re: Do you believe in God
Fortunately, developmental biologists don't give up quite so easily. The key paper is Truman, J. W. and L. M. Riddiford, 1999. The origins of insect metamorphosis. Nature 401: 447-452.Matthew Turner wrote:It is not clear to me how a process of gradual Darwinian Evolution could result in a process of metamorphosis. That almost seems contradictory?
Even if we didn't have a good idea of how metamorphosis works, divine intervention is not a valid explanation, given the absence of any evidence for how that could happen.
All multiverse hypotheses are speculative; none is accepted as a good theory at present. M-Theory is the leading contender, but it lacks predictive power and empirical testability. Cosmologists certainly find the idea interesting, but evidence is lacking. What they're looking for is some aspect of our universe that would differ between a single universe theory and a multiverse theory - then they can test the theory and see which one best describes reality.Matthew Turner wrote:I don't think there is 'multiverse theory' but there a great many theories based around the idea of strings and additional dimensions and the like which would all fall under a multiverse umbrella. I think most scientists would say that one of these theories was the best that we had at present.
Ian Kingston
http://www.iankingston.com
http://www.iankingston.com
-
- Posts: 456
- Joined: Sat Oct 11, 2008 9:56 pm
Re: Do you believe in God
Matt - do you believe that humans evolved through natural selection and share a common ancestor with birds, reptiles, fish, insects etc? How old do you believe The Earth is?Matthew Turner wrote:YesNick Thomas wrote:There are many things that science cannot yet explain. Your butterfly example is a strange choice as an example. But my rather uninformed attempt is: By Darwinian evolution in gradual increments by means of natural selection over a long period of time.Matthew Turner wrote:Robert Thompson wrote
"1) Why should i believe in something there is no evidence for?"
There are some things that Science cannot explain. How did butterflies evolve? for example. Is it scientific to simply discount the possibly of a creationalist entity?
If you consider the 'multiverse' theories of science which I think most scientists believe in today, then with many many universes to consider isn't it much more likely that in one there exists a supremely powerful entity which one might call God for short?
It is not clear to me how a process of gradual Darwinian Evolution could result in a process of metamorphosis. That almost seems contradictory?
No it is not scientific to discount any possibility but then again no scientist would do that. Science is not by definition dogmatic and scientists are therefore always open to review new evidence and change their view accordingly. What makes you think that most scientists believe in the multiverse theory?
I don't think there is 'multiverse theory' but there a great many theories based around the idea of strings and additional dimensions and the like which would all fall under a multiverse umbrella. I think most scientists would say that one of these theories was the best that we had at present.
Certainly most think it a possibility. What do you mean "one might call god for short"? Are you lumping all sorts of different types of gods into the pot?
If you are lumping all "gods" together then perhaps one could imagine one (or many) who is likely to exist somewhere. Perhaps I could suggest a being so far advanced of others in intellect and technology that I could lump him/her/it into the god set. I would still insist that they evolved in some way from the bottom up though rather than being craned in from godland.
-
- Posts: 153
- Joined: Sat Apr 25, 2009 4:21 pm
Re: Do you believe in God
It is sad that I can't help but compulsively follow this thread.
If nothing else, it's both amusing and tedious at the same time.
BTW, there are specialised religious forums if you are interested. Not that I wish to inflict more atheists on them.
If nothing else, it's both amusing and tedious at the same time.
BTW, there are specialised religious forums if you are interested. Not that I wish to inflict more atheists on them.
AKA Scott Stone
"Give a man fire and he's warm for a day, set fire to him and he's warm for the rest of his life."
That's Mr Stone to you, f**kface.
"Give a man fire and he's warm for a day, set fire to him and he's warm for the rest of his life."
That's Mr Stone to you, f**kface.
-
- Posts: 456
- Joined: Sat Oct 11, 2008 9:56 pm
Re: Do you believe in God
I like you Sebastian. You remind me of myself when I was young and craved attention...
-
- Posts: 153
- Joined: Sat Apr 25, 2009 4:21 pm
Re: Do you believe in God
Ha. Ha.Nick Thomas wrote:I like you Sebastian. You remind me of myself when I was young and craved attention...
But seriously, once you've seen the same arguments repeated year on year it gets a bit tedious.
AKA Scott Stone
"Give a man fire and he's warm for a day, set fire to him and he's warm for the rest of his life."
That's Mr Stone to you, f**kface.
"Give a man fire and he's warm for a day, set fire to him and he's warm for the rest of his life."
That's Mr Stone to you, f**kface.
-
- Posts: 456
- Joined: Sat Oct 11, 2008 9:56 pm
Re: Do you believe in God
That is a good point! Actually my purpose in starting this thread was not to debate the existence of god as I am well versed in the arguments and am fairly clear on my stance. I am actually interested in what makes educated people believe in god. How do they go from not believing in Thor, Zeus, Santa Claus God etc to becoming convinced that a god exists.Sebastian Stone wrote:Ha. Ha.Nick Thomas wrote:I like you Sebastian. You remind me of myself when I was young and craved attention...
But seriously, once you've seen the same arguments repeated year on year it gets a bit tedious.
-
- Posts: 541
- Joined: Sat Dec 01, 2007 10:03 pm
- Location: Leicester
Re: Do you believe in God
Perhaps for your next investigation, you could prove or disprove the existenceNick Thomas wrote:That is a good point! Actually my purpose in starting this thread was not to debate the existence of god as I am well versed in the arguments and am fairly clear on my stance. I am actually interested in what makes educated people believe in god. How do they go from not believing in Thor, Zeus, Santa Claus God etc to becoming convinced that a god exists.Sebastian Stone wrote:Ha. Ha.Nick Thomas wrote:I like you Sebastian. You remind me of myself when I was young and craved attention...
But seriously, once you've seen the same arguments repeated year on year it gets a bit tedious.
of consciousness.
-
- Posts: 3604
- Joined: Fri May 16, 2008 11:54 am
Re: Do you believe in God
Yes, the slug in my garden may accord me the status of God. From it's perspective, I have existed from beyond it's comprehension of the beginning of it's universe and I will go on (hopefully) beyond it's comprehension of the end of it's universe. I hold it's life and death in my hands. If a being existed that had a similar relationship to me as I had to my slug, would I be wrong to call him, her or it God?Nick Thomas wrote:
Matt - do you believe that humans evolved through natural selection and share a common ancestor with birds, reptiles, fish, insects etc?
There is a lot of evidence to suggest that this true.
How old do you believe The Earth is?
Last weekend I listened to two very eminent academics tell me it was 13.7 billion years old. I accept that they have studied the subject in much greater detail than me. However, I also think that it is an interesting idea that if everybody believes something to be true then it must by definition be false. Science is evolutionary and theories are forged in the furnace of debate, where no debate exists, science stagnates and its theories have the status of folklore.
If you are lumping all "gods" together then perhaps one could imagine one (or many) who is likely to exist somewhere. Perhaps I could suggest a being so far advanced of others in intellect and technology that I could lump him/her/it into the god set. I would still insist that they evolved in some way from the bottom up though rather than being craned in from godland.
-
- Posts: 456
- Joined: Sat Oct 11, 2008 9:56 pm
Re: Do you believe in God
Call it what you like but I would like to suggest that we give it the attribute of being hauled up by some form of evolution rather than being craned in fully formed.Matthew Turner wrote:Yes, the slug in my garden may accord me the status of God. From it's perspective, I have existed from beyond it's comprehension of the beginning of it's universe and I will go on (hopefully) beyond it's comprehension of the end of it's universe. I hold it's life and death in my hands. If a being existed that had a similar relationship to me as I had to my slug, would I be wrong to call him, her or it God?Nick Thomas wrote:
Matt - do you believe that humans evolved through natural selection and share a common ancestor with birds, reptiles, fish, insects etc?
There is a lot of evidence to suggest that this true. Enough to convince you that it is true?
How old do you believe The Earth is?
Last weekend I listened to two very eminent academics tell me it was 13.7 billion years old. This is the normal estimate for the age of the universe, the age of the earth being about 4.5 billion years old. I accept that they have studied the subject in much greater detail than me. However, I also think that it is an interesting idea that if everybody believes something to be true then it must by definition be false.I don't understand this at all. Are you talking about the argumentum ad pupulum? If so you appear to have misused it here. Science is evolutionary and theories are forged in the furnace of debate, where no debate exists, science stagnates and its theories have the status of folklore.But the crucial part of science is not the theorising, it's the experimentation and confimation of prediction.
If you are lumping all "gods" together then perhaps one could imagine one (or many) who is likely to exist somewhere. Perhaps I could suggest a being so far advanced of others in intellect and technology that I could lump him/her/it into the god set. I would still insist that they evolved in some way from the bottom up though rather than being craned in from godland.
-
- Posts: 1726
- Joined: Thu Apr 19, 2007 3:10 pm
- Location: Kingston-upon-Thames
Re: Do you believe in God
Five misplaced apostrophes in one sentence (and six in all). Is this a record? There should be a forum rule - three 'its and you're out.Matthew Turner wrote:Yes, the slug in my garden may accord me the status of God. From it's perspective, I have existed from beyond it's comprehension of the beginning of it's universe and I will go on (hopefully) beyond it's comprehension of the end of it's universe. I hold it's life and death in my hands. If a being existed that had a similar relationship to me as I had to my slug, would I be wrong to call him, her or it God?
Personal Twitter @johnchess
Britbase https://www.britbase.info
(I prefer email to PM - contact me via this link - https://www.saund.org.uk/email.html)
Britbase https://www.britbase.info
(I prefer email to PM - contact me via this link - https://www.saund.org.uk/email.html)
-
- Posts: 456
- Joined: Sat Oct 11, 2008 9:56 pm
Re: Do you believe in God
I don't think, anyone else, but you cares, John,
-
- Posts: 1726
- Joined: Thu Apr 19, 2007 3:10 pm
- Location: Kingston-upon-Thames
Re: Do you believe in God
Do you have evidence for that belief or is it a leap of faith?Nick Thomas wrote:I don't think, anyone else, but you cares, John,
Personal Twitter @johnchess
Britbase https://www.britbase.info
(I prefer email to PM - contact me via this link - https://www.saund.org.uk/email.html)
Britbase https://www.britbase.info
(I prefer email to PM - contact me via this link - https://www.saund.org.uk/email.html)
-
- Posts: 456
- Joined: Sat Oct 11, 2008 9:56 pm
Re: Do you believe in God
don't know, but i'm just, glad you're understanding the topic of the thread, as well as apostrophising,