I've just noticed that I had already identified W S Wallis as William Scott Wallis when publishing the JM Aitken file. I should have checked that before finalising the revised draft of the 1956 Grading List with forenames, with which this thread began. My apologies for this and one or two other similar oversights on my part. BritBase, grown huge like Frankenstein's monster, occasionally threatens to overwhelm its creator.Christopher Kreuzer wrote: ↑Mon May 27, 2024 11:08 am
That has to be [W S Wallis]. I am intensely curious now to know whether it was him that replaced William Winter in the 1939 British Chess Championships!
The 1939 event was under-reported, probably because the outbreak of war was obvious and attention was elsewhere. But surely contemporary sources must make clear whether it was P. N. Wallis or W. S. Wallis?
...
I will need to leave this now, but it deserves its own thread as not everyone will be reading this one.
The 1939 Bournemouth event was not under-reported. There were daily reports in the Times, the Manchester Guardian, other regional newspapers and substantial coverage in BCM. All UK reports that I have seen have referred to P N Wallis so the NYT is very much out on a limb. Note that the NYT report was dated 17 August 1939 - the same day that Flohr played Wallis - so it is not a matter of them copying an earlier newspaper source. (The article is behind a pay wall so I don't have full access to it.) I suppose it must have been an error on the part of whoever reported for that paper, who might have had an existing note of the name W S Wallis, put 2 and 2 together and made 5. We've all done it.
Philip Norman Wallis (1906-1973) would be rather more deserving of a separate thread than W S Wallis - he was a strong player - but fortunately Steve Mann has already done most of the leg work at his excellent Yorkshire Chess History website: https://mannchess.org.uk/People/Wallis,PhilipNorman.htm - chess history buffs will be used to seeing PNW's name followed by residence details such as Sheepy Parva (one of my favourite chess player residences - no doubt the 'Parva' was a necessary qualifier to distinguish it from the seething metropolis that was Sheepy Magna) or Leicestershire, but Steve Mann tells us that "Philip and [his wife] had by 1939 seemingly moved to 6 Cranes Park, Surbiton, which is where they were living in 1939, apparently as lodgers in the household of one Septimus Beresford Weller." It was only after WW2 that P N Wallis took up residence in Leicestershire. So the residence details ("of London") given in most 1939 Bournemouth reports are correct.